For your keepsake welcome sign, I’m envisioning a framed canvas. I know you mentioned you weren’t sure about having a frame, but I think this option would give you the most polished look while still keeping that true canvas feel. The frame also helps finish off the edges nicely, especially with the torn paper detail, so everything looks intentional and elevated. Since the artwork wouldn’t be behind glass, you’d still get the full effect of the textures and layers. I can share some examples if you’d like!

To give you a better sense of what I have in mind, I put together a very rough sketch. This is just a loose idea and not at all a reflection of the final piece—it’s simply to show the direction I’m thinking.

For the artwork itself, I’m picturing layered watercolor and acrylic-painted paper with the possibility of subtle gold accents. We can include your names and wedding date to keep it timeless and versatile so it can easily be displayed in your home afterward. The colors would reflect your fall palette, with lots of warm neutrals woven throughout.